• 2452閱讀
  • 40回復

ESPN 評本屆世界盃最佳陣容與最差陣容 [復制鏈接]

上一主題 下一主題
離線火鳳凰
 
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看樓主 倒序閱讀 使用道具 樓主   發表于: 2010-07-12
World Cup Best XI

Goalkeeper: Eduardo (Portugal)

It has not been a vintage tournament for goalkeeping or, by extension, goalkeepers but Eduardo has provided a welcome exception. Portugal left South Africa after conceding a solitary goal, to Spain, in a match when Genoa's new signing had denied David Villa on several occasions before he managed the winner. In a group stage where he kept three clean sheets, outstanding saves from Nilmar and Ramires were further indications of his quality.

Right back: Philipp Lahm (Germany)

If Gabriel Heinze isn't still troubled by the thoughts of Philipp Lahm sprinting past him with embarrassing ease, it should be a surprise. Germany's captain showed that he retains his considerable prowess when overlapping in the rout of Argentina. Yet it was also a World Cup to enhance his reputation for doing the basics efficiently: Lahm helped silence the feared Argentine attack and was secure at the back against Spain.

Centre back: Carles Puyol (Spain)

His stylish sidekick Gerard Pique is capable of striking inch-perfect 50-yard passes, but Carles Puyol has been the most resolute defender in the Spanish side. While his younger partner has conceded a penalty and was among the culprits for Switzerland's winner, Puyol has been the epitome of reliability. And it was his thumping header that clinched Spain's place in the World Cup final for the first time.

Centre back: Ryan Nelsen (New Zealand)

So which of the following sides ended the World Cup unbeaten: Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Spain and New Zealand? Were the question posed five weeks ago, the answers may have been split between the first four. As it is, the All Whites drew with the reigning champions, acquitted themselves terrifically and exited without defeat. A reason for each of those achievements was Ryan Nelsen, who defended defiantly and, against Italy, heroically. Before the tournament, it would have seemed surreal to suggest Nelsen would pip Lucio to a place in a team of the tournament. He has.

Left back: Carlos Salcido (Mexico)

The second round contained a cruelty for attacking full-backs. The two finest left-footers in South Africa were sent home early: Portugal's dynamic Fabio Coentrao and Mexico's accomplished Carlos Salcido. The latter struck the crossbar against Argentina but peaked with a wonderful display in the defeat of France. A fine crosser of the ball, he looked a class act.

Centre midfield: Bastian Schweinsteiger (Germany)

He won his 80th cap in the semi-final defeat to Spain, but this feels like the World Cup when Bastian Schweinsteiger came of age. He has relished the responsibility of anchoring the midfield and played with the positional awareness and discipline of a footballer who had spent years in the role, rather than the late convert he actually is. Against both England and Argentina, Schweinsteiger dominated the game and was the outstanding player on the pitch in both thrashings.


Centre midfield: Xavi (Spain)

It is no coincidence that Xavi has spent much of the tournament topping FIFA's passing statistics. There is no finer distributor of the ball in the world game and, while playing ahead of two anchor midfielders seemed to suggest he would see less of the ball, that has not been the case. Wherever he is stationed on the pitch, everything goes through Xavi.

Right wing: Thomas Muller (Germany)

Few have risen so swiftly or as auspiciously. Thomas Muller has been catapulted from Bayern Munich reserves to Germany's starting line-up within a year and had such an impact that, were he not harshly suspended, it is tempting to wonder if the scoreline of the semi-final against Spain would have been different. The five goals scored displayed a precocious awareness, an ability to drift into dangerous positions and, above all, a happy habit of putting the ball in the back of the net.

Attacking midfielder: Wesley Sneijder (Netherlands)

Long after most of the notional world-beaters had failed to live up to their billing, Wesley Sneijder remained in South Africa and remained the exception. A wonderful year at Inter Milan was compounded by a terrific World Cup with Sneijder displaying his remarkable passing range, scoring at the rate of a striker and exerting an influence throughout the knockout rounds.

Left wing: David Villa (Spain)

He isn't really a left winger, but David Villa has done such a fine job there for much of this World Cup that he operates there in this team. Most strikers score fewer goals when they move further out; Villa has managed as many, whether from a few yards or, as against Chile, from 45. On current form, quite simply the best goalscorer in the world.

Striker: Diego Forlan (Uruguay)

Admittedly Diego Forlan has spent some of his tournament in deeper positions but, as he displayed against Netherlands in the semi-final, his ability to retreat and create should not detract from his status as an outstanding centre forward. In any case, the presence of Villa in this team means he can go into attack when Forlan veers elsewhere. Long-range shooting and set-pieces, two areas in which few players have excelled, but the Uruguay talisman has mastered. Few have played with more commitment, either.

Substitutes: Justo Villar (Paraguay), Maxi Pereira (Uruguay), Lucio (Brazil), John Mensah (Ghana), Fabio Coentrao (Portugal), Mark van Bommel (Holland), Xabi Alonso (Spain), Arjen Robben (Netherlands), Mesut Ozil (Germany), Robinho (Brazil), Miroslav Klose (Germany).

Manager: Joachim Low (Germany)

The man who has rebranded German football as youthful, enterprising and eminently watchable, Joachim Low's World Cup ended 24 hours early but was otherwise glorious. Restoring Miroslav Klose and Lukas Podolski to potent forces, rather than Bundesliga underachievers, was a sign of fine management; the way his faith in the untried trio of Thomas Muller, Mesut Ozil and Sami Khedira was rewarded was another; and the demolition of first England and then Argentina showed Low's tactical prowess. Shame about the dress sense, though.
離線火鳳凰
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 1  發表于: 2010-07-12
World Cup Worst XI

Goalkeeper: Robert Green (England)

In a World Cup where the brand of ball became first a noun and then a verb, plenty of goalkeepers proclaimed themselves Jabulani-ed. Sometimes, however, that was no excuse. Poor Robert Green committed the kind of mistake against USA that defines a career and not just a tournament. The basics are well known: Clint Dempsey shoots, Green lets it slip through his hands and acquires international infamy.

Right back: Jonas Gutierrez/Nicolas Otamendi (Argentina)

Right back can appear the easiest position to play on the pitch. Argentina, who didn't pick any specialists, proved that isn't necessarily the case. In the first two games, Jonas Gutierrez displayed all the positional sense of a left winger playing at right back; unsurprising, given that is what he was. Then centre-back Nicolas Otamendi took over. His duel with Germany's Lukas Podolski was among the most one-sided of the World Cup. Suffice to say that the substituted Argentine didn't win it.

Centre back: John Terry (England)

Perhaps the most elementary error a central defender can commit is to misjudge a goal kick and let it bounce behind him; that was what John Terry did when Miroslav Klose gave Germany the lead against England. There is a temptation to say Terry was all over the place but, more accurately, he was rarely in the right position and lacked the speed to get there. As it is cited as the reason for his dire display against the Germans, he plays as the right-sided centre back in this team.

Centre back: William Gallas (France)

Swift to blame Raymond Domenech after France's dismal campaign concluded, William Gallas nonetheless admitted his own form hadn't been brilliant. That is an understatement. His partnership with Eric Abidal rarely threatened to work and it should mark an undistinguished end to his international career.

Left back: Patrice Evra (France)

The Manchester United defender began his career as a striker. For 24 hours, he reverted to that role when organising the futile French boycott of training. It was not Evra's finest moment; nor, indeed, was it when Mexico's Pablo Barrera sped past him with unusual ease en route to winning the penalty for their second goal. Evra was duly dropped for the final game. As Raymond Domenech manages this team, Evra captains it (though presumably John Terry would attempt to take it off him).

Centre midfield: Gennaro Gattuso (Italy)

Time has been cruel to too many of the Italians. Four years ago, Gennaro Gattuso was the Azzurri's enforcer, an all-action midfielder at the peak of his game. Now only the trademark beard is the same; brought in to stop Marek Hamsik, an anonymous Gattuso was hauled off at half-time against Slovakia. It was a sad farewell to international football.

Centre midfield: Felipe Melo (Brazil)

Felipe Melo's short fuse had long been apparent in Serie A. When it became a problem on the international stage, it did so with huge consequences. Brazil were already trailing to Netherlands, after two goals credited to Wesley Sneijder but where Melo was partly culpable, when he planted his studs in Arjen Robben's thigh. Blaming the Dutchman for his dismissal was unfair; it was Melo's fault and it was the moment that effectively ended Brazil's World Cup hopes.

Right wing: Franck Ribery (France)

This has not been Franck Ribery's year. Overshadowed emphatically by Arjen Robben in Bayern Munich's fine campaign, he was suspended for the Champions League final. Eligible for the World Cup, he was shunted around the forward line, proving especially ineffective in the hole. While he set up France's only World Cup goal, scored by Florent Malouda, and was the better of two poor right wingers - Sidney Govou was shocking - Ribery's pedigree means he qualifies as the greater underachiever.

Left wing: Cristiano Ronaldo (Portugal)

FIFA presumably wouldn't agree with this; Cristiano Ronaldo was somehow named man of the match in each of Portugal's three group games. Perhaps it was merely wishful thinking, though the Portugal captain did have a fine second half against North Korea; then again, so did the entire side. But Ronaldo's only goal proved irrelevant and, when Portugal required inspiration against Spain, he was unable to oblige.

Striker: Wayne Rooney (England)

Four games, no goals: in everything other than a red card, Wayne Rooney's World Cup was rather too similar to his tournament in 2006. Then, as now, he did not appear to have fully overcome an injury; then, as now, the system did not seem to suit him; then, as now, a reputation as one of the world's leading players was not justified.

Striker: Nicolas Anelka (France)

Nicolas Anelka and Raymond Domenech did not see eye to eye in South Africa
The man who achieved the dubious honour of becoming the first player, among those who played in the World Cup, to leave it, Nicolas Anelka contrived to do rather more damage in his own dressing room - where his outburst at Raymond Domenech brought his expulsion from the French camp - than he did to opponents. Two anonymous displays may be forgotten easily, but the French civil war won't be.

Substitutes: Federico Marchetti (Italy), Gabriel Heinze (Argentina), Fabio Cannavaro (Italy), Eric Abidal (France), Giorgios Karagounis (Greece), Claudio Marchisio (Italy), Kaka (Brazil), Sidney Govou (France), Alberto Gilardino (Italy), Fernando Torres (Spain).

Manager: Raymond Domenech (France)

Others failed, but none so humiliatingly and yet so predictably. That Raymond Domenech was out of his depth was obvious in Euro 2008, yet he retained his position for another two years. Tactics, team selection, man-management and even basic dignity appeared beyond him. That his players have queued up to blame Domenech is no surprise: the shock will be if any club or country offers him a swift return to employment.
離線火鳳凰
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 2  發表于: 2010-07-12
見有人出左個所謂「英評」,我又出過另外一個先……
發帖
41012
好友元
29305
閱讀權限
66104
貢獻值
8
只看該作者 3  發表于: 2010-07-12
個陣容同我心水大部分都同意,

不過門將我會選卡斯拿斯

後衛唔要沙斯度,中場四個一樣,

前面加個高路斯
四星德國!!KING OF THE WORLD 2014

離線ODIN
發帖
29780
好友元
0
閱讀權限
29780
貢獻值
5
只看該作者 4  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第2樓火鳳凰2010-07-12 16:45發表的“”:
見有人出左個所謂「英評」,我又出過另外一個先…… [表情]


呢個正路好多...

Manager: Joachim Low (Germany)

The man who has rebranded German football as youthful, enterprising and eminently watchable, Joachim Low's World Cup ended 24 hours early but was otherwise glorious. Restoring Miroslav Klose and Lukas Podolski to potent forces, rather than Bundesliga underachievers, was a sign of fine management; the way his faith in the untried trio of Thomas Muller, Mesut Ozil and Sami Khedira was rewarded was another; and the demolition of first England and then Argentina showed Low's tactical prowess. Shame about the dress sense, though.

離線ming仔
發帖
49086
好友元
230
閱讀權限
49088
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 5  發表于: 2010-07-12
卡卡係唔好,但未至於Worst?
發帖
41012
好友元
29305
閱讀權限
66104
貢獻值
8
只看該作者 6  發表于: 2010-07-12
阿根廷果兩個右後衛入選,係咪因為輸比德國果場扣哂分
四星德國!!KING OF THE WORLD 2014

發帖
41012
好友元
29305
閱讀權限
66104
貢獻值
8
只看該作者 7  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第4樓liuming12-07-2010 16:52發表的“”:
呢個正路好多...
Manager: Joachim Low (Germany)
.......


兩年前接手仲係寂寂無名

估唔到真係有料到
四星德國!!KING OF THE WORLD 2014

離線ming仔
發帖
49086
好友元
230
閱讀權限
49088
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 8  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第6樓謊大童2010-07-12 16:53發表的“”:
[表情] 阿根廷果兩個右後衛入選,係咪因為輸比德國果場扣哂分 [表情]

係.........

都係果句啦,如果有辛尼迪...........
離線火鳳凰
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 9  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第5樓名稱已被使用2010-07-12 16:53發表的“”:
卡卡係唔好,但未至於Worst? [表情] [表情] [表情]


我諗佢個 worst 既意思係同本身水準作比較,如果唔係既話,俾人大炒七球既北韓無理由無人入選……
離線火鳳凰
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 10  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第6樓謊大童2010-07-12 16:53發表的“”:
[表情] 阿根廷果兩個右後衛入選,係咪因為輸比德國果場扣哂分 [表情]


應該係啦,而且兩個都唔係正宗右後衛……
離線ODIN
發帖
29780
好友元
0
閱讀權限
29780
貢獻值
5
只看該作者 11  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第7樓謊大童2010-07-12 16:54發表的“”:
[表情] [表情] 兩年前接手仲係寂寂無名
估唔到真係有料到


十分鐘意low...
我覺得佢同forlan係今屆最大的驚喜...
離線火鳳凰
發帖
91264
好友元
54168
閱讀權限
91264
貢獻值
2
只看該作者 12  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第4樓liuming2010-07-12 16:52發表的“”:
呢個正路好多...
Manager: Joachim Low (Germany)
.......


呢個最實至名歸︰

Manager: Raymond Domenech (France)

Others failed, but none so humiliatingly and yet so predictably. That Raymond Domenech was out of his depth was obvious in Euro 2008, yet he retained his position for another two years. Tactics, team selection, man-management and even basic dignity appeared beyond him. That his players have queued up to blame Domenech is no surprise: the shock will be if any club or country offers him a swift return to employment.

離線ODIN
發帖
29780
好友元
0
閱讀權限
29780
貢獻值
5
只看該作者 13  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第12樓火鳳凰2010-07-12 16:58發表的“”:
呢個最實至名歸︰
Manager: Raymond Domenech (France)
.......



the shock will be if any club or country offers him a swift return to employment.

真係好mean...
發帖
41012
好友元
29305
閱讀權限
66104
貢獻值
8
只看該作者 14  發表于: 2010-07-12
引用第11樓liuming12-07-2010 16:57發表的“”:
十分鐘意low...
我覺得佢同forlan係今屆最大的驚喜...


奇哥時代主張踢法類似英超式既主攻,快攻,但弱點就係防線推得太前,暴露唔少空間;

到路維接手,開始以控球在腳為主,前鋒線由兩個減至一個,

打多個中場,先係中場取得主導權,加上陣容偏向年輕化,

令德國拎到球後變相提升打反擊既速度,

後防將A費移入中路都係德國取得佳績既另一個主因。

今屆四個後防都打得好好,包位、落腳、默契都好少出現瑕疵。

不過路維最唔好既一樣就係換人既調動,只係識換高美斯,同埋從來無乜點重用傑斯寧。
四星德國!!KING OF THE WORLD 2014